Jump to content

Clarification with Christmas Magic Event


hunter
 Share

Featured Comment

Hey! All so, as title said I just wanted a clarification with the result of winner for Best Christmas Tree Challenge who managed by Mr. @Rade and Mr. @Stefan which Dobriak is the winner . I could say that his entry is really awesome but if we are going to rely on the requirements. I think he didn't follow it correctly.  

 

As per requirement 

 

To prove you're the one making the entry, in the picture/video you should hold a piece of paper with following hand-written content:
   • 'Stake Christmas '20'
   • Date of submission
   • Your Stake username

If you didn't meet any of the requirements of the contest, you can be disqualified. 

 

but as you can see there is no person who is holding a piece of paper.

image.thumb.png.bf2cf658a4c11f80dcfbaf5d546ed499.png

 

 

If we are going to based on the requirement it didn't passed but still he won ? Then I wanted to clarify what's the purpose of having a rule if its ok not to follow it? 

 

Anyways the reason why I'm reacting is because If ever you agree on what I'm saying that he didn't meet the requirements . I wanted you to look at my entry as I also put effort to it like what Dobriak did. 

 

133545921_900965190707259_6010922373050383115_n.thumb.jpg.bea694f5f71230a2b0e5a56e9edbe08a.jpg132887195_218302609875469_5753657459710722397_n.thumb.jpg.49acf319ce8784e68ca251757085136c.jpg133737860_136472254908852_6027829619481912256_n.thumb.jpg.ffdafdedc643d2e2cea05a514f459df3.jpg

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 1/5/2021 at 3:22 AM, hunter said:

Hey! All so, as title said I just wanted a clarification with the result of winner for Best Christmas Tree Challenge who managed by Mr. @Rade and Mr. @Stefan which Dobriak is the winner . I could say that his entry is really awesome but if we are going to rely on the requirements. I think he didn't follow it correctly.  

 

As per requirement 

 

To prove you're the one making the entry, in the picture/video you should hold a piece of paper with following hand-written content:
   • 'Stake Christmas '20'
   • Date of submission
   • Your Stake username

If you didn't meet any of the requirements of the contest, you can be disqualified. 

 

but as you can see there is no person who is holding a piece of paper.

image.thumb.png.bf2cf658a4c11f80dcfbaf5d546ed499.png

 

 

If we are going to based on the requirement it didn't passed but still he won ? Then I wanted to clarify what's the purpose of having a rule if its ok not to follow it? 

 

Anyways the reason why I'm reacting is because If ever you agree on what I'm saying that he didn't meet the requirements . I wanted you to look at my entry as I also put effort to it like what Dobriak did. 

 

133545921_900965190707259_6010922373050383115_n.thumb.jpg.bea694f5f71230a2b0e5a56e9edbe08a.jpg132887195_218302609875469_5753657459710722397_n.thumb.jpg.49acf319ce8784e68ca251757085136c.jpg133737860_136472254908852_6027829619481912256_n.thumb.jpg.ffdafdedc643d2e2cea05a514f459df3.jpg

 

 

@hunteractually , i have raised that question on chatroom from the host of this event coz i've noticed some who missed that requirement  when in fact it  is clearly stated  and even highlighted... and seems it was not strictly followed.

As to my entry.. i was very observant of the rules or requirements so i did my art craft in accordance with the requirements so i was so confident of winning it.

just hope that next contest if there will be..judges should adhere with their given requirements.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

49 minutes ago, Zamia2001 said:

@hunteractually , i have raised that question on chatroom from the host of this event coz i've noticed some who missed that requirement  when in fact it  is clearly stated  and even highlighted... and seems it was not strictly followed.

As to my entry.. i was very observant of the rules or requirements so i did my art craft in accordance with the requirements so i was so confident of winning it.

just hope that next contest if there will be..judges should adhere with their given requirements.

Yeah I hope @Dan will read this and have a solution for this concern . I rarely join event like this and now that I joined I feel like I was cheated ;( . 

 

There's no point of putting requirements/rules and high lighting  it if they are going to pick entries who clearly didn't follow the requirements. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 1/9/2021 at 1:39 AM, Dan said:

Whats the problem here? You want the winner to be disqualified?

Were you disqualified?

 

If ever YES because it's unfair for me and for the other user who comment on my post it means it's not only me who have issues with that. The prize was sent already to winners who didn't deserve it because regardless how beautiful their creations are, they still need to follow the rules like what we did. I'm very observant of the rules I know I deserve to win but I cannot deny that dobriak entry is better but like what I've said he didn't follow the rules. He must be disqualified I must say.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Forum Admin
10 hours ago, hunter said:

If ever YES because it's unfair for me and for the other user who comment on my post it means it's not only me who have issues with that. The prize was sent already to winners who didn't deserve it because regardless how beautiful their creations are, they still need to follow the rules like what we did. I'm very observant of the rules I know I deserve to win but I cannot deny that dobriak entry is better but like what I've said he didn't follow the rules. He must be disqualified I must say.

That is an absolutely ridiculous take, closing topic.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...